Toilet Paper Wrap Put in Garbage Recycle With Plastic Bags Plastic bags, wrap, and plastic film materials are not accepted in the curbside recycling because they can jam sorting equipment at the recycling facility. To ensure plastic toilet paper wraps get recycled, bring them to a participating plastic film drop-off location. Otherwise, please place in your black refuse container. Ways to Reduce Buy Toilet Paper That’s Packaged Only Once Switching to toilet paper that is only packaged once will cut down on your household’s plastic waste. Depending on the brand, some toilet paper is sold in compostable boxes.